Disposable Diapers vs. Cloth Diapers in an Inflated Economy
Preface: This post is based on a large quantity (156) package of disposable diapers purchased at Amazon.com which is significantly cheaper than the smaller (32ish) packages that most people purchase due to costs. Β It is also based on the fact that the larger the baby, the larger the size they will need and although the package of the diaper stays the same, the number of diapers in the package is less, therefore making the per diaper cost more expensive. Β It is also based on one brand of diapers.
I read, yesterday that the price of disposable diapers is going up, possibly 7%!! Β Outrageous. Β But then again, thinking about it… all the resources they use making them – they have to go up sooner or later. Β We’re not just talking about diapers that sit in the landfills taking 250-500 years to decompose. Β We’re also talking about the over 300 pounds of wood, 50 pounds of petroleum feedstocks and 20 pounds of chlorine are used to produce disposable diapers for one baby EACH YEAR per The Real Diaper Association. Not to mention.. look at all the money being literally pooped on and thrown away.
Don’t you think it’s time to make the switch to cloth diapers? Β Seriously, check this out.
When we used paper/trash diapers, Huggies was the brand we used most. Let’s talk aboutΒ Huggies Snug & Dry Diapers, Size 3, 156-Count for a second. Β These would be considered size Medium if they were cloth diapers because they fit 16-28 pounds. Β For a medium baby, 16 pounds, approximately 3 months old, approximately 8-12 diapers per day , this box would last you approximately 19 days for 8 diapers and only 13 days (less than 2 weeks) if 12 diapers per day.
The numbers below represent a boxes of 156 diapers purchased for a sale price for an average of 8 to 12 diapers used per day (there will be days that it’s more, or less), and an average of three years that it takes a child to be out of diapers. Β Remember, if you buy diapers in smaller packages, these numbers will rise drastically.
- Sale price of $31.91
- $0.20 per diaper
- $1.60 – $2.40 Β per day
- $11.20 – $16.80 per week
- $44.80 – $67.20 per month
- $537.60 – $806.40 per year
- $1612.80 – $2419.20 per the average 3 years until potty
You’re throwing away your hard earned money.
Per Seeking Alpha
- Kimberly-Clark (KMB) is raising prices for diapers and bathroom tissue as it tries to deal with increasing costs. The consumer products company said Thursday that it will raise prices in North America for its baby, child care and consumer tissue businesses in the second and third quarters.
- Kimberly-Clark said Thursday that net selling prices for items likeHuggies diapers will go up 3% to 7% on average in the U.S. and Canada. Net selling prices for CottonelleΒ bathroom tissue will likely rise about 7% in the U.S.
So, how does that change the cost of purchasing Huggies disposable diapers?
Remember, right now:
- $1612.80 – $2419.20 per the average 3 years until potty
3% – 7% increase will translate to:
- $1661.18 – $2491.78 per 3 years at 3%
- $1725.70 – $2588.54 per 3 years at 7%
Cloth Diapers save Money and the Environment!
Now, let’s talk about cloth diapers. Β Because they come in a 12 pack on Amazon WITH a bag of Rockin’ Green Cloth Diaper Detergent if you buy the 12 pack, and they are a really popular brand, let’s talk about FuzziBunz One Size Pocket Diapers – and how much money they will save if you take good care of them. Β These diapers are known to last for years and years and years if properly cared for.
These numbers are calculated for a 12 pack of FuzziBunz cloth diapers purchased on Amazon.
- $227.40 – 12 pack
- $18.95 per diaper
- $227.40 per year
- $227.40 per the average 3 years until potty
Now, let’s just say, for grins and giggles, you don’t want to wash every day, and you decide to go ahead and purchase two 12 packs of FuzziBunz One Size Pocket Diapers.
- $454.80 – Β 24 pack
- $18.95 per diaper
- $454.80Β per year
- $454.80Β per the average 3 years until potty
Now, let’s go ahead and add another baby in the mix. Β Now, you have two in diapers. Β You can continue to buy Huggies diapers for BOTH babies, doubling your diapering costs, OR you can continue to use the same two 12 packs of FuzziBunz One Size Pocket Diapers with both babies and possibly adding one more 12 pack to your stash to make things a little easier wash wise.
Huggies Snug & Dry Diapers, 156-Count (before inflation and 3% – 7% price increase)
- $1075.20 – $1612.80 PER YEAR for two babies.
- $3225.60 – $4838.40 per the average 3 years until potty
3 sets of 12Β FuzziBunz One Size Pocket Diapers
- $682.20 per the diapering lifetime of all your children!
Not to mention, once you’re done with children, or you decide you’d rather purchase a different cost effective cloth diapering system, you can donate your diapers to an organization like Giving Diapers Giving HopeΒ (info below) so that a family in need can benefit from your cloth diapers for years to come.
Of course, if you’re worried about your water bill and electric bill increase, just look at those numbers. Β There’s no way you’re going to up the cost to even out the impact that disposable diapers not only have on your family’s pocket book , but on your children’s future in the environment as well. Β Many people either do not notice a rise in the cost or they only notice cents or a few dollars each month.
Still not sure about Cloth Diapers?
I challenge you to Change 3 Things. Change 3 Things is an awareness campaign designed to promote the environmental and economical impacts of cloth diapering. Changing three cloth diapers a day is a small change for one family that equals big impact for our planet.
If you’re worried about the initial cost, no fear, check out Giving Diaper Giving HopeΒ which is aΒ non-profit organization that provides education, support and cloth diapers to low income families in the continental United States!
Take the Cloth Diaper plunge!!
Outrageous! Super informative article…hopefully more mamas will be convinced to try out cloth. Another plus – The cloth dipe butt is sooo darn cute!
They are cute, aren’t they? They even use them in a lot of commercials and articles because it’s cuter. THanks Mel!
This just reinforces why I cloth diaper…yeah the environmental benefits are good but my favorite thing is never having to worry about where the money to buy diapers comes from. Thanks for writing this article, I am so going to share it on my FaceBook page.
I hear that! Having to scrap up money to run to the store on a Sunday isn’t cool! Thank you!
We used cloth from the beginning with our daughter and I LOVE THEM. They are much prettier, softer and I just feel so much better knowing my little girls parts are wrapped in clean cotton, not paper and who knows what else. My daughter is now 19 months and daytime potty trained, but all my diapers are still in such great shape they will be used for #2 and beyond.
Great article. I hope it opens some eyes!!
Yeah, I didn’t even want to touch on the chemicals in this article! π Thank you!
4th kid….first time cloth user….so easy to use and way cheaper than disposables…plus so good for the environment…
And.. no more late night trips to the store! π Good luck Kelly! π Thank you!
I’ve been using cloth diapers since my son was 10 days old and I’m SO glad!! Between that and breast feeding, my son hasn’t cost us much at all.
I’m also planning on splurging on a ‘fancy’ cloth diaper with some of our tax refund (thanks to having a baby!). Haha!
On top of BFing and CDing, I’m also making clothes for our new baby to be! π I’m excited! Congrats, love! Hope you get a new fancy diaper soon! π
I used cloth diapers when my children were babies because disposables were not readily available at that time. I doubt that I would use disposables today if I were having babies, simply because of the landfill issue. And cotton cloth diapers just seem to be more kind and gentle to a baby’s behind, in my opinion. Would you want to wear plastic and paper on your bottom every day for three or four years? I think not.
My mom used them on us because there wasn’t an option, but if she had it to do all over again… she wouldn’t, which is sad. π Thanks Karen! You’re right. I’d not wear paper and plastic and all that other junk! <3
We switched to cloth when our 2nd child was 13 months old. We did it just as much for the money as well as not wanting those NASTY chemicals on our kids. We bought most of our stash as seconds (small factory defects or gently used). We’ve spend about $250 and we have about 25 one-size diapers that our (now) 20 month old is in, and our 3 week old will be in as soon as she’s about 10lbs. In that $250 are also prefolds and covers for the tiny baby. We also use cloth wipes. My husband was weary at first, but he DEFINITELY notices the extra money each month, that we AREN’T spending on diapers. He also notices how CUTE cloth diapering our 2 daughters is!
I switched to cloth when he was deployed, so he was bombarded with it when he came home… but he loved it instantly!
What a great article! And if people are really interested in starting but worried about cost. CDF is a great option as well as buying diapers at close to half price from daily deal sites for parents!
The next article I write will be about saving with prefolds, I think. WIth this one, I wanted to show, that even on the “trendy” end of cloth diapering it’s so much cheaper than disposables! I’m glad you made the switch and that he’s dealing with it nicely! Hats off to your hubs! We are thankful for his service and to you for being his wife. <3
I used both cloth & disposables for my oldest child and only cloth for my youngest. The cost of disposables was just too much to throw away. Even when you figure in washing & drying cloth is more economical. Cloth is also so much easier now than it used to be! Besides I don’t wear paper undies…why should my baby? π
We have gone back and forth from time to time, like when we have gone out of town or something, and I just hated knowing that I could have used that money for a tank of gas! <3 And paper undies definitely wouldn't be cool!
What a great article– Always love information on Cloth diapers!!
Thank you! π
I’m thrilled I made the change to cloth with my third baby and wish I had done the same with my older two. My husband wasn’t totally on board at first but he’s glad we made the change as well.
My hubs has always been a go with the flow gy! I’m glad yours is on board now! π
To save even more money you can buy used or make your own cloth diapers!
You’re right, and I will be touching on that soon! THANK YOU! I might make this a series! π
Wow,I knew we had been throwing away money but I never realized it was that much!We switched all three kids to cloth this past fall and I wish we would have done it from the beginning.We use Fuzzibunz OS for a 3 yr.old and 16 month twins and I can’t believe how easy it is.Plus,we bought them all of Craigslist and Diaper Swappers so we saved even more,not to mention resale value when we are done using them.This article has recommited my desire to cloth diaper.Thanks!
I really sure have mentioned the resale values. I think I’ll do another post, soon tying into this one. Thank you for the reminder! And you’re right. It doesn’t have to cost $277ish for 12! If you get them already used, it’s so much cheaper!
I felt so overwhelmed reading those numbers! The cost of disposable diapers is so high. I think people really need to do more in depth research…the one this article provides. Looking in the long term, geez…why NOT cloth diaper? Thank you for this! I will be sharing it!
I felt really overwhelmed when calculating them! π Now, those are just to get an idea, really. The numbers will vary from brand to age to size, but putting it in numbers makes it really overwhelming!! Thank you! π
Awesome article! I’m so glad we switched our son to cloth when he was 4 months old! I’m hoping to see more mamas switching π
We switched when our daughter was 3. She was no longer in diapers during the day but she was at night. NOw, we have baby #4 on the way, and I can’t imagine spending that kind of money! π
I cloth diaper mainly because the thought of contributing that much waste to a landfill and mucking up the world that my children will be living in long after I am dead, makes me sick. If ONLY to help save the world, please, please, please use cloth diapers! It’s so easy and makes sense to the environment! Yes, they are cute too.
I think the movie Wall-E hit it on the head. What do people think is going to happen when all the trees are gone… and everything is just in piles? I think people don’t realize it because they’ve never seen a dump or a landfill in their lives.
HOA’s get so mad, and neighbors get so mad when they see houses with junk all around the outsides.. yet those same people are sending junk to some other spot on the Earth.. Makes no sense!
We decided to cloth diaper for environmental reasons, fell in love with the cute factor and made it a passion thanks to the cost savings.
Our stash paid for itself by the time baby 5 months old and that included a lot of impulse buys because I just couldn’t resist a cute print. I don’t need to buy any more diapers and I’m amazed at how the savings add up.
I just keep thinking about just HOW MUCH money that is! It’s crazy.. and you’re right, it does start adding up… I didn’t even TOUCH on wipes!
LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this post! This is exactly why we made the switch–to save $, and we’re also glad to be helping benefit creation and our babies’ bums!
I’m sharing this article!! Thanks for all you did to put this together!
By the way–I’m the BLESSED recipient of the CDF’s generosities!!
Thank you! π CDF is glad to have you!
So I love cloth and didn’t do it for economical reasons and according to this I still saved. I would say I spent around 1500 on my stash for my twins which is around the same for paper diapers for 1 child for 3 years. So by buying fancy cloth I diapered 2 for the price of one. Further more the twins are now 3 and just potty trained, but I also have a 1 year old using their old diapers. So in the end I will diaper 3 for the price of one. I didn’t notice the savings so much with the twins building up my extensive stash. My husband would say this costs the same as our oldest. True, but that was one and this was for 2. Now though my youngest is one and I’ve spent a total of $15 on a diaper I couldn’t pass up :).
Hehe… and then there are some people π But yeah, it’s addictive, isn’t it?? π Thank you!
I am a 46 year old mom of four. I cloth diapered my four children and now am raising twin step grandsons. They are almost four months old and in cloth all the way! On their visitations with thier parents I do have to put them into sposies as they visit at a public facility and afraid since, I am not there the diapers would be thrown away!
I just love your story, Leta. Since you first emailed, you’ve had my heart. <3.
Just had to add we are the Johnston’s too! π
<3<3
Awesome article! And I hadn’t heard about the imminent price hike in disposable diapers – yikes! Just like a previous commenter – I’m a fourth-time mom, but first time cloth user. HOW I WISH I’d thought to research “modern” cloth diapering sooner!! Thank goodness my younger sister, who at the time was pregnant w/ her first, sent me some links about cloth diapering. I started reading and thought, “Hey, I could do this!” Soon I was preparing for the birth of our fourth baby and building up a stash of cloth diapers for her. We started using the cloth when she was 4 days old and have never regretted it. Contrary to what the disposable diaper industry wants parents to think, cloth diapers actually function BETTER than their paper version. Better at containment, more absorbent, better fit, etc., etc. And cloth is NOT hard or gross to take care of.
When I think about all the $$$ wasted on disposable diapers for my first three, I want to bang my head on the desk! Which is why I try to be as vocal as possible (hopefully w/o being annoying!) about how awesome and easy cloth can be. Off to share this on facebook… π
Thank you! You’re right. A new couch, possibly a vacation, down payment on a vehicle…. crazy money wasted!
Great article. I was just talking about the economy of diapers last night with my teen daughter and her best friend. They both want to use cloth diapers for their babies when they get married and have them. It is easy to encourage cloth diaper use when they see how easy they are to use, how economical they are and most of all, how stinking cute they are.
I’m a mom of 8 and have used cloth for 4 of them. I will be passing your article along.
Thank you! There’s a store, locally, that sells cloth diapers, and I always love it when sposie moms come in and are curious! <3
So are we supposed to use cloth toilet paper too? The cost of tp is going up, but I don’t see any of you jumping up and down to switch to reusable/washable bathroom tissue.
Actually, there are many people who do! You’d be surprised! I use my baby’s cloth wipes (velour) as TP! π
When we installed our diaper sprayer I was amazed at how much I liked using it myself, especially as a woman, during certain times of the month π Feels nice and clean and refreshing. Hey, Europeans have bides, it’s not a new concept. Save on tp that way!
Also, in the kitchen, we have a roll of paper towels that RARELY gets used. I bought a bunch of cheap wash cloths at a large chain cheap store, and we use those for messes around the kitchen, and also to wipe the babies hands and face after he eats. Different colors for different uses, including dishes and cleaning the stove and counters. I keep 2 baskets on the window sill above the sink, one for clean wash cloths, one for dirty. We use them all the time (I must have used 3 of them today to get DS’s hands and face clean already).
We probably go through one roll of paper towels every 6 months (unless the dog pukes, then we use paper towels – yuck!)
That’s an awesome idea Susy about the different colors for different uses! π
I love my thirsties and my snap-ez diapers. I’d like to try some wool someday though (maybe sbish). π
I love Thirsties! They’re a GREAT GREAT supporter of the cloth diaper foundation as well !): Wool is fab! π
Okay… so the price for the Huggies are slightly off. For that size box at Wal-Mart it is $25.00. But still that price is outragious!
I would have loved to use cloth diapers on all of my children but when I looked into it with my oldest… I could not find a single day care center that would accept cloth diapers. So during the time she was at day care she would have to wear disposables and cloth while with me. Financially at the time, it was better for us to go with disposable diapers. We were young and poor and could not afford the cloth diapers at the time. They are very reasonable priced and if there would’ve been the Cloth Diaper Foundation back then it would’ve helped so much.
I searched on Walmart.com for the price, to make sure it was comparable.. http://www.walmart.com/ip/HUGGIES-Snug-N-Dry-Diapers-sizes-1-2-3-4-5-6/12024959
Size 3, Huggies, 156 Count.. $31.90.
It’s probably going to vary depending on where you live!
I’ll do another post another day about how CHEAP it is to use prefolds! You think it’s cheap to use FuzziBunz…. haha wait til you see prefolds!
I would LOVE to survey people who buy sposies. That would be an AWESOME senior project!
We switched to cloth when my daughter was 10 months old. (4 months ago). I wish I had done it sooner! My almost 3 year old son is almost completely potty trained except for night time. We continued to buy diapers for his nights but recently bought cloth trainers for his night time needs. We have saved so much money. We used to live near my in-laws and they purchased our diapers for us as a way to help us. So we never really noticed the true cost of diapers. We maybe bought a package a month. Shortly after my daugther was born we moved away and had to buy all our diapers and started calculating the cost. I am also glad we have less trash. Shortly after switching to cloth I started using cloth wipes too. It is amazing to me how much easier it is! My cloth keeps her drier at night than a disposable ever has. We got our diapers from the cloth diaper foundation and it has been such a blessing. We have been able to purchase a few diapers on our own and the trainers for my son. We would never have been able to do this without organizations like the CDF!
Great information. I’ve wanted to do cloth diapers. My mother used them with my brother and sister. I am much older than them and had to deal with the diapers, too. So I know how easy it really can be. But it’s my husband that needs the convincing. I’ll forward this to him. Oh, an we have to pay about $1 per trash bag to the dump in our little country town. That’s about $2-3 per week just in diapers. $2 x 52 = $104 Multiply that by 3, that is $312 at least for our 1 child!!!
And this is why it still baffles me that I had to FIGHT my husband to use cloth diapers.
Since my daughter was preemie, the cloth I -had- didn’t fit her. So until my tiny cloth diapers came it, I am ashamed to say we used disposables.
I think after the one week of them equaling about $45, he realized that I was right and it really WOULD save us a lot of money.
And those were with the gDiapers.
I’m currently working on switching him over to regular cloth diapers, which will save even more money.
Just one question — how much for laundry? That seems to kill me with diapers and the like. I don’t see any costs for that included here so I’m assuming you’re not using any detergent or soap, and just beating them on the rocks in the creek? π
Now, now, no need to be rude. The author does briefly mention slightly increased water and power costs associated with the increased laundry, but asserts that the cost savings are still significant when compared with the cost of using disposables (the increased cost of trash pickup with disposables isn’t included in that calculation either).
If you are looking for real information, I don’t mind sharing our personal experience with actual costs (which will, of course, vary depending on your local utility costs). I wash diapers three times a week. Both our water and electricity bills went up about $10 per month during between May and November, during which time I line dry them outside as often as possible. Line drying is recommended if you have the resources as it is easier on the PUL and elastic and also sun bleaches out the stains. Some people use drying racks on apartment decks or inside during the winter months but my house doesn’t allow for that. The increased costs during the winter of using the dryer are hard to calculate since we also have electric heat and a simple comparison to the previous year isn’t valid as I am at home with our baby now rather than working (and therefore heating the house more). I do use a special type of detergent just for the diapers due to my daughter’s sensitive skin. We buy it in bulk and it is about $30 for a 6 month supply. I haven’t done a cost comparison with regular detergent.
On the other side, during the three months that we used disposables before she grew into the cloth diapers, we spent an extra $15 per month for a larger trash bin.
So, in terms of monthly costs, they are certainly higher than they were before we had our baby. However, the argument isn’t about whether your family costs go up when you add a child but whether it is cheaper to diaper them one way rather than another. Now that we are adding our second child, the savings is even more noticeable since we have made the investment in cloth already. The water and power costs probably won’t go up a lot more either since I will wash full loads of diapers instead of the partials that I do now.
Thank goodness the days of river washing or stovetop boiling of diapers are over!
We used ‘gifted’ sposies on our son until he was about 3 1/2 months. When I put the first ‘real’ diaper on him, he got so happy and excited. When we first put a sposie back on him to go out of town for the weekend, he threw a fit!!!! Now–at 2 1/2–he calls them ‘paper diapers’ and asks for a ‘real diaper’. (Not much of an issue anymore as he is basically potty trained) Hubby was on board from the get go and never had any trouble with them–even washing out a poopy one in the toilet! I made most of our stash and only spent about $100 on materials! Will definitely be using cloth for any future babies! BTW . . . . . I decided it wasn’t fair that Baby had cloth and I didn’t–made myself a set of cloth Mama Pads and would NEVER go back to sposies for myself either!!!
I use disposables. I was so intimidated by all the info on cloth. It sounded like I needed special detergent, certain diaper rash creams and the toilet hose thing- though it was the special way to wash that really confused me. And we wond even get into the different types of cloth! I tried the gDiaper with the disposable inserts, but they were a terrible fit on my baby, leaving deep red marks on her thighs even when she was at the bottom of the weight range for the size. So, that was money wasted! I think the cost of specialty detergents, and the cost of experimentation to find the right diaper should be considered.
And what about using the extra water to wash? Or is just the diaper services that have a big environmental impact?
We switched to cloth when my 6 yr old was about 6 months old. I didn’t notice a difference in our water bill. I also don’t use any special detergents or anything.
As for the different styles/brands- almost everything we’ve tried fits fine although we do have our preferences. But the resale value of cloth diapers is really good- lots of time I’ve sold them for close to what I’ve paid- definitely can’t do that with a disposable diaper!
We are super cheap with our cloth diapers because I just happen to love prefolds and making my own recycled wool covers! π
The extra water to wash is comparable with the extra water the child will use to flush after being potty trained. So it’s a matter of adding it now with the diapers or later when the child is potty trained.
We cloth diapered. At first it wasn’t a money issue. My son was HYPER sensitive to everything. He broke out in eczema type skin irritation from disposables.. Once I seen the savings though, it really helped me to keep going once he was over the rashes!! I loved cloth!
Love me some fluffy butts!